“Transcendental Philosophy and Atheism”


Wayne M. Martin




This paper is now in print in

The European Journal of Philosophy

Vol 16, Number 1 (April, 2008), 109-130




EJP does not permit electronic posting of accepted

papers until 12 months after publication.

Contact the author for further information.




wmartin –AT– essex.ac.uk





ABSTRACT:  Engineers test materials by subjecting them to stress:  once a beam has been broken one can specify exactly how strong it was.  The same method can be used in philosophy.  In the Autumn of 1798 and the Winter of 1799, Fichte’s philosophical position was submitted to extraordinary stress in the extended episode known as the Atheism Controversy, culminating in his forced dismissal from his university post at Jena.  The disputed issues explicitly concerned matters of religious faith and philosophical theology, but the stress of the controversy exposed fundamental tensions in Fichte’s broader philosophical position and provoked him to formulate a novel, proto-phenomenological account of the scope and structure of transcendental investigation.